American Horror Story: Horror Moment
For me, the all-time scariest moment in American Horror Story: Asylum is this scene when Shelley wakes up on Arden’s table like wtf happened to my legs. And the part when she’s walking up the stairs at the middle school is also terrifying, probably second scariest. I would have said the scariest moment in the show is the damn credits but I guess that doesn’t really count lol. Scariest season of American Horror Story yet.